SOCIAL AND ECOLOGICAL ISSUES
3.1 social and ecological issues: Video Clip
We see four friends, Lindsy, Sarah, Ariella and Michael, walking outside a classroom at school. Suddenly Lindsy gets a message. Her online order, a new dress, has arrived at her home. Sarah and Michael react irritably: does she really need so many clothes? Doesn’t this contribute to the negative consequences of climate change? Shouldn’t we all think more about our buying behavior and our (over)consumption? Ariella gets involved in the discussion and defends Lindsy: climate change is not Lindsy’s fault. Ariella points to Christianity as the big culprit of the current climate crisis. Michael and Sarah are confused, how can Christianity be to blame for the climate crisis? And is this really the truth? Is it really true that Christians are responsible for all of this? Are today’s Christian believers not interested in this problem? When the friends leave on a camping trip, they get an answer to all their questions...
3.2 Caring for our planet: time for action?!
ASSIGNMENT. Read the statements above and answer the following
Are you worried about climate change? Why yes/no? What worries you the most?
In what way do you try to take care of the earth?
Do you have any idea how the Catholic Church handles the care of our planet?
3.3 The Catholic Church and the care for our planet
Things are not going so well with the earth, environment, and climate
right now. Humans have polluted the earth, and this has led to the current
climate crisis. The climate crisis manifests itself, particularly in global
warming. This warming has several serious consequences for man and
nature, such as health problems, the extinction of animal species, water
scarcity, the deterioration of available fertile land, natural fires, extreme
weather conditions, conflicts between population groups, and so on.
For Christians, caring for the earth is very important. Christians believe that God created the earth. The earth is thus God’s creation and Christians want to take care of all of His creation.
To better understand this, we are going to read the story of creation. This is a story from the book of Genesis, the first book of the Old Testament.
3.3.2 The importance of Genesis 1
ASSIGNMENT. In the text, indicate verses
In the biblical text, indicate verses …
• That you do not like;
• That surprise you;
• That you do not understand.
The story of creation is a very old text written a long time ago in a very
different culture than ours. This story can be found in the book Genesis.
This is the first book of the Old Testament. The Old Testament is more than
2000 years old. Although Bible stories were written a long time ago, they can
still have an important meaning for us.
If we think about the relationship between man and nature, what can we learn from the creation story today? We will discover this step by step below.
3.3.3 All human beings are created in the image of God. What does this mean?
ASSIGNMENT. In the Bible fragment, it is written that humankind was created in the image of God. What does this mean?
Michelangelo - ‘The Creation of Adam’
ASSIGNMENT. Read the text below, and filll in the missing words.
care – responsible – symbolic meaning – reign – literally
If you read the Bible story in a literal way, it may indeed seem that man,
as the one in charge, can
over the earth and thus do what he
wants with nature and animals. Yet this is not the message of the story. You
should always look at the
of every Bible story. This means
that you must look and think beyond the words that are
written down. Moreover, in Bible texts, you should not look for facts, but
rather look at the images and symbols used to express a vision of God, the
world and humankind.
Genesis 1 teaches us that man was created in the image of God. This means that man must for the creation of God, the earth, just as God would do. It means that man is for nature, animals and other people. Creation is a precious gift from God with which man must deal in a caring manner.
3.3.4 Man will ‘rule’. What does this mean?
ASSIGNMENT. Below you can find the Bible story again. Indicate in the Bible story the verses that make it seem that man is allowed to rule over the earth.
Which verses make it seem that man is allowed to rule over the earth?
ASSIGNMENT. Do you think that humans today, as rulers, abuse the earth, nature and animals? Why yes/no? Is this an appropriate attitude?
ASSIGNMENT. “God saw everything that he had made, and indeed, it was very good” (Genesis 1:31). Would he think so today? Why yes/no? What would you ‘recreate’ in the existing world?
3.4 And what about caring for our fellow human beings?
The story of creation does not only want to tell us something about how humans should deal with nature. Man, just like all plants and animals, is part of creation. So, the story of creation is not only about caring for nature and animals, it is also about caring for others.
Did you know that climate change has a major impact on human relationships? Climate change can lead to a shortage of drinkable water or food, health problems, extreme weather (heat, drought, torrential rains), and so on. Because of the consequences of global warming, the living environment of more and more people is under threat. This can lead to a source of frustration and discussion among people! So, caring for the climate is also related to caring for each other!
ASSIGNMENT. Read the quote above. Do you agree with this quote? Why do you/do you not?
ASSIGNMENT. What can you personally do to take more care of the earth and of others?
Anthropocentrism is the tendency to put the human being at the center of the universe and consider him as the only point of reference. In this view, man is seen as the culmination of creation and can therefore rule over the earth.
In a symbolic reading of the Bible story about the Sacrifice of Isaac, we may also ask ourselves whether we are making an ‘Isaac Sacrifice’ today. Sacrifices are part of life. They teach us to reflect upon ourselves. This is also called ‘to bring an Isaac Sacrifice’. For believers, such an Isaac Sacrifice can cause them to question not only their image of humanity but also their image of God.
The story of creation
The story of creation is a very old text written a long time ago in a very different culture than ours. The story of creation can be found in the book Genesis. This is the first book of the Old Testament. The Old Testament is more than 2000 years old. Although Bible stories were written a long time ago, they can still have an important meaning for us.
BELGISCH OBSERVATORIUM MAATSCHAPPELIJKE ONGELIJKHEID, Het milieu als bron van
ongelijkheid? Armoede en sociaal de-engagement in de stad, https://ongelijkheid.be/Het-milieuals-
bron-van?lang=fr (access 22.10.2020).
C. BENNETT, Failure to act on climate change means an even bigger refugee crisis, in The Guardian, 07.09.2015.
C. BRABANT, Een Post-Kritische Scheppingsspiritualiteit. Van een onkritische kijk naar een tweede naïviteit, in J. HAERS & M. SERVAAS (ed.), Wanneer de schepping kreunt in barensweeën. Hedendaagse reflecties over Schepping, Antwerpen, Halewijn, 2008, p. 55-56.
D. POLLEFEYT & J. HENDRICKX, Letter en Geest. Christelijke ingrediënten voor actueel godsdienstonderwijs. Deel 3, Brussel, Licap, Halewijn, 2020, p. 92, p. 130, p. 182, p. 186, p. 317- 318.
D. POLLEFEYT (ed.), Caleidoscoop 2. Handleiding leerkracht, Mechelen, Plantyn, 2016, p. 14-43.
D. POLLEFEYT (ed.), Caleidoscoop 2. Handboek leerling, Mechelen, Plantyn,2016, p. 7-32.
D. POLLEFEYT (ed.), Caleidoscoop 2. Werkboek leerling, Mechelen, Plantyn,2016, p. 1-26.
D. POLLEFEYT, Holocaust and nature, Wien, LIT, 2013.
D. POLLEFEYT, The Bible in the Ecological Debate: Obstacle or Guide?, in D. POLLEFEYT (ed.), Holocaust and nature, Wien, LIT, 2013, p. 115-125.
E. ROOZE, Schepping is bevrijding. Verrassende ecologie in de Bijbel, Antwerpen, Halewijn, 2009.
E. VAN STICHEL, Fair Trade of Bio? Plichten tegenover huidige en toekomstige generaties, in J. HAERS & M. SERVAAS (ed.), Wanneer de schepping kreunt in barensweeën. Hedendaagse reflecties over Schepping, Antwerpen, Halewijn, 2008, p. 89.
E. VAN WOLDE, Verhalen over het begin. Genesis 1-11 en andere scheppingsverhalen, Baarn, Uitgeverij Ten Have, 1995, p. 41-42.
H. AUSLOOS & B. LEMMELIJN, De bijbel: een (g)oude(n) gids. Bijbelse antwoorden op menselijke vragen, Leuven, Acco, 2005, p. 99-114.
H. DEBEL & P. KEVERS (ed.), Terug naar waar het begon. Het boek Genesis herlezen, Leuven, VBS, Acco, 2017.
J. DE SCHEPPER, Wat christenen geloven, Tielt/Wommelgem, Uitverij Lannoo NV/Uitverij Van In, 2006, p. 82-83.
J. DE TAVERNIER & M. VERVENNE (ed.), De mens: hoeder of verrader van de schepping?, Leuven, Acco, 1990, p. 31-32, p. 60-61.
J. HAERS & M. SERVAAS (ed.), Wanneer de schepping kreunt in barensweeën. Hedendaagse reflecties over Schepping, Antwerpen, Halewijn, 2008.
JUNIOR COLLEGE THEOLOGIE EN RELIGIEWETENSCHAPPEN, Jaargang 2, Module 2: Is de wereld om zeep? Schepping, religie en crisis, https://www.kuleuven.be/onderwijs/juniorcollege/ geesteswetenschappen/copy_of_themas#crisis (access 26.10.2020).
KATHOLIEKE DIALOOGSCHOOL, Youth for Climate, https://www.kuleuven.be/thomas/page/ youth-for-climate/ (access 05.10.2020).
KERKNET, Dag van de aarde: herontdek de 16 mooiste citaten uit Laudato si’, https://www. kerknet.be/kerknet-redactie/artikel/dag-van-de-aarde-herontdek-de-16-mooiste-citaten-uitlaudato- si%E2%80%99 (access 05.10.2020)
M. VERVENNE, Mens, kosmos en aarde. Een exegetische reflectie over Genesis 1-3, in J. DE TARVERNIER & M. VERVENNE (ed.), De mens. Verrader of hoeder van de schepping?, Leuven, Acco, 1991, p. 27-62.
MILIEUDEFENSIE VOOR VERANDERAARS, Hoe klimaatverandering bijdraagt aan de vluchtelingencrisis, https://milieudefensie.nl/actueel/hoe-klimaatverandering-bijdraagt-aan-devluchtelingencrisis (access 22.10.2020).
NRSV, Genesis 1:26-31, https://www.biblegateway.com/ passage/?search=Genesis+1&version=NRSV (access 13.11.2020).
R. BURGGRAEVE, De bijbel geeft te denken. Schepping, milieu, lijden, roeping, Gods passie en de ander, vergeving, bevrijding van de ethiek, in gesprek met Levinas, Leuven, Acco, 1991, p. 45-48.
R. BURGGRAEVE, Eigen-wijze liefde. Fragmenten van Bijbels denken, Leuven, Acco, 2000, p. 55-57.
THOMAS, Aardewerk. Zorg voor de schepping, https://www.kuleuven.be/thomas/page/ aardewerk/ (access 02.10.2020).
THOMAS, Abel. Laudato Si’, https://www.kuleuven.be/thomas/page/abel-laudato-si/ (access 02.10.2020).
THOMAS, Abel. Recontextualisering, https://www.kuleuven.be/thomas/page/abelrecontextualisering/ (access 02.10.2020).
THOMAS, Dossiers. Vredesweek 2009, https://www.kuleuven.be/thomas/page/ vredesweek-2009/ (access 22.10.2020).
THOMAS, In de Kijker. De tuin van heden, een kosmos van vervuiling of vervulling?, https://www. kuleuven.be/thomas/page/tuin-van-heden/ (access 02.10.2020).
THOMAS, In de Kijker. Wanneer de Schepping kreunt in barensweeën, https://www.kuleuven.be/ thomas/page/schepping/ (access 02.10.2020).
UITGEVERIJ AVERBODE, Spirit@school 5e jaar. Tussen hemel en aarde, Averbode, Uitgeverij Altiora Averbode, 2012. UNSPLASH, Unsplash. Photos for everyone, https://unsplash.com/ (access 02.10.2020).
VATICAN, Encyclical letter Laudato Si’ of the Holy Father Francis on our Care for our Common Home, http://www.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/encyclicals/documents/papafrancesco_20150524_enciclica-laudato-si.html (access 18.09.2020).
VREDE.BE, De link tussen klimaatverandering, conflict en vluchtelingen, https://www.vrede.be/nieuws/de-link-tussen-klimaatverandering-conflict-en-vluchtelingen (access 22.10.2020).
WIKIPEDIA, De schepping van Abraham, https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_schepping_van_Adam (access 22.10.2020).