TEXT OF VIOLENCE
Why were the youngsters initially reluctant to help refugees?
In the biblical narration of the Exodus, which people are involved
In the biblical narration, which sea did the pursued people cross, in order to be saved:
Why, in the biblical narrative, God is depicted to act violently and vengefully?
For Christians, God is the One who:
2.3 What I need to know in order to study the Bible story
2.3.1 Historical and social context
Check the following information, along with the map (see 3.3) and the summary table (3.2) with the protagonists, events and dates.
The story of the crossing of the Red Sea* can be found in the book of Exodus* in the Old Testament*. This book includes the events that took place around the 13th century BCE and reveal God’s intervention in history with the aim of liberating the Israelites from the Egyptians and leading them to the land of Canaan*. The Israelites lived in Egypt from 1600 to 1200 BCE, for approximately 400 years. When Ramses II* became Pharaoh (1290–1224 BCE), he took strict measures against them, fearing they would ally with other peoples of the desert and revolt against him. One such measure was the killing of Jewish male children to limit their number. Moses* was born at that time, and was miraculously saved from death. He was chosen by God to liberate the Israelites and lead them to the land of Canaan*.
On their way to the land of Canaan*, the Israelites did not follow the shorter, coastal route. Instead, in order to avoid the Egyptian guards, they headed south to the Red Sea*. Pharaoh at that time was Merneptah* (1224–1204 BCE), the successor of Ramses II*. With his army, Merneptah* pursued the Israelites as far as the sea, but he could not prevent them from fleeing, because God opened a passage for them through the sea. Marching through the sea, they were able to proceed to the desert and were saved. In commemoration of this important event, Israelites celebrate “Pesach*” (=passage) even today, as the crossing of the Red Sea* marked their passage from slavery in Egypt to freedom.
During this period, God makes a Covenant, i.e. a Testament* with His people and at the same time protects them, supports them, cares for them, strengthens and guides them. On the other hand, the people relate to him, trust him and recognize him as unique and omnipotent.
2.4 The crossing of the Red Sea
Then the Lord said to Moses: 2 Tell the Israelites to turn back and camp in front of Pi-hahiroth, between Migdol and the sea […] 10 As Pharaoh drew near, the Israelites looked back, and there were the Egyptians advancing on them. In great fear the Israelites cried out to the Lord. […] 13 But Moses said to the people, “Do not be afraid, stand firm, and see the deliverance that the Lord will accomplish for you today; for the Egyptians whom you see today you shall never see again. 14 The Lord will fight for you, and you have only to keep still.” 15 Then the Lord said to Moses, “[…] Tell the Israelites to go forward. 16 But you lift up your staff, and stretch out your hand over the sea and divide it, that the Israelites may go into the sea on dry ground. 17 Then I will harden the hearts of the Egyptians so that they will go in after them; and so I will gain glory for myself over Pharaoh and all his army, his chariots, and his chariot drivers. 18 And the Egyptians shall know that I am the Lord, when I have gained glory for myself over Pharaoh” […] 21 Then Moses stretched out his hand over the sea. The Lord drove the sea back by a strong east wind all night, and turned the sea into dry land; and the waters were divided. 22 The Israelites went into the sea on dry ground, the waters forming a wall for them on their right and on their left. 23 The Egyptians pursued, and went into the sea after them, all of Pharaoh’s horses, chariots, and chariot drivers. […] 26 Then the Lord said to Moses, “Stretch out your hand over the sea, so that the water may come back upon the Egyptians, upon their chariots and chariot drivers.” 27 So Moses stretched out his hand over the sea, and at dawn the sea returned to its normal depth. As the Egyptians fled before it, the Lord tossed the Egyptians into the sea. 28 The waters returned and covered the chariots and the chariot drivers, the entire army of Pharaoh that had followed them into the sea; not one of them remained. 30 Thus the Lord saved Israel that day from the Egyptians; and Israel saw the Egyptians dead on the seashore. 31 Israel saw the great work that the Lord did against the Egyptians. So the people feared the Lord and believed in the Lord and in his servant Moses.
In the following exercises, you can process the biblical text by identifying
words and phrases that show God to act violently and then to investigate
why the biblical writer presents God to be violent and vindictive.
Which of the following adjectives would you use to describe the God you encounter in the text?
Find and underline in the Bible text the phrases that show God’s wrath towards the Egyptians.
In the same text, mention sentences which show the reasons for God’s violent actions.
Seeking for the deep interpretation
The biblical narration we read, describes a God who uses violence against humans. Let’s read the following text and try to understand why the author of the Bible presents God like this. Maybe we need to consider something else?
Based on the fact that the recording of historical events by biblical writers
takes place many centuries after the events themselves, try to answer the
To which extent are these events accurately described? Do they include exaggerations because they serve other purposes? What are the purposes of this record?
2.5 SO FAR...
… we have learned … understood … clarified
In the Old Testament*, the narration of the crossing of the Red Sea*
(Exodus* 14:1-31) contains scenes of violence. It is violence exercised by
God against the Egyptians, whom he eradicates, thus saving the people of
Israel from their persecutors. Approached literally, this narration describes
a God who is biased in favor of one particular nation and uses violence to
bring another one to destruction.
The core of the historical events of Exodus* took place around the 13th century BCE; however, the relevant texts of the Old Testament* were recorded much later, in the 6th to 5th century BCE. The motivation for writing down narrations which had been passed down orally over centuries was not the study of history (in the contemporary sense of an accurate, objective understanding of events); but rather, it reflected concerns for the significance these narratives could have for people at the time of their recording. People of that era had already developed civilization, had settled in cities and their living conditions were essentially different from those of the period of the events narrated. Therefore, the references of the Scriptures are not intended to provide exact historical information, as we understand it today, but rather to elaborate eternal theological truths, that will remain valid as long as there are people on Earth.
Biblical authors attempted to graphically illustrate, absolutely and leaving no room for doubt, the omnipotence of the one and only God, in contrast to the weakness or even the non-existence of the pagan deities of that time. Thus, their goal was to emphasize that their God is a unique, omnipotent protector and liberator. Every time they lived through difficult and dramatic situations, he was present and saved them from every evil. Their profound conviction was that they could not cope with the hardships of life on their own, but God, through his saving interventions, protected their every righteous struggle.
Approaching the narration of the crossing of the Red Sea*, as well as all the narrations of the Old Testament*, from this perspective, we are able to understand the significance they have for us today and distinguish between the “sacred history” found in these texts and the objective history describing actual events.
2.6 The image of true God
Through the following questions, taking the video and the text of the Old Testament* as a starting point, we can investigate the image of God the Father, a God of love for all.
2.6.1 Exercise 1
In the video, in the scene where Yiorgos chats with his mother about the
rescue of the refugees*, he asks “Mom, do you think God can do evil?”
to which she answers, “Since we call him Father, I cannot imagine him
harming his children.”
What can the phrase “God is Father” mean to a Christian?
In order to answer, we will use the following text from the New Testament*:
Speaking to his disciples, Jesus says: “You have heard that it was said, ‘You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.’ But I say to you, Love your enemies, bless those who curse you, do good to those that hate you and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven; for he causes his sun to rise on both the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous.” (Mt. 5:43- 45)
“Father” means that:
2.6.2 Exercise 2
God is Father to all men. Why, then, when we feel fear of the stranger and
of the unknown, do we often need a strong God who protects only us and
annihilates the one we fear?
When we are afraid, our image of God, but also of our fellow humans, is often affected by our insecurity. How can we deal with our fears towards strangers? In the following paragraph, underline the keywords that answer the above question. Explain your choice.
Let’s remember what we saw in the video: Yiorgos shares his father’s fear of the supposedly “dangerous” refugees* and thus he remembers the story of the Old Testament*. In the end, however, the youngsters’ contact and acquaintance with the refugees* eliminates the fear and creates feelings of friendship and familiarity with them.
2.6.2 Exercise 2
According to the Christian tradition, God is …
… Father, who loves all people with no exceptions and discriminations. God- Father, being Love himself, calls all of us to love all of our fellow humans, even our enemies, if we want to be his real children.
2.8 Additional Assignments: Material for further discussionFigure 2.6 Marc Chagall, The Crossing of the Red Sea, 1955
Clarification of theological terminology, and also information on the historic personalities and places found in the book.
In the Old Testament, refers to the land settled by the Israelites, but also by its “Canaanite” inhabitants. The name means “country of purple” (Greek name “Phoenicia”) and comes from the main export product of the region, a substance used to dye fabrics deep purple. The land of Canaan is the Promised Land; the fulfillment of God’s promises to the people of Israel by enabling them to settle in this area after leaving Egypt.
Christians keep the same Jewish name for their own celebration, Easter, when they remember Jesus Christ, who through His Crucifixion and Resurrection gave man the prospect of life, and freedom from death and evil in all its manifestations. They celebrate the restoration of life in its entirety and its victory over death which was brought by Jesus Christ. features.
The book of Exodus is the second book of the Bible and the Hebrew Bible and belongs to the historical books of the Old Testament. Exodus, together with the books of Genesis, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy is the Pentateuch (in Hebrew Law (Torah). In the Greek translation of the Septuagint (LXX) it was called “Exodus”, because the central issue is the exit (ie the liberation) of the Israelites from slavery in Egypt. The protagonist in the Exodus is Moses.
Merneptah (1224-1204 BCE)
The 3rdson of Ramses II and his wife Isetnofret (and 13th son of Ramses, overall). With his army, Merneptah pursued the Israelites to the sea, but was unable to prevent them from fleeing. context than Mecca.
Charismatic personality of the Jewish nation and religion. Moses was a leader, a hero, a legislator, a prophet and a mediator between God and his people. He led the people of Israel to liberation from the Egyptians, crossing the Red Sea and through the Sinai Desert for 40 years. According to Jewish and Christian tradition, Moses received the 10 commandments from God. He receives special honour as a prophet from both Christians and Muslims.
Oral Traditions (Old Testament)
Words and narratives that Jews, both men and women, repeated to each other outside their tents in the desert, and in their homes, whether hovels or palaces. At the heart of these narratives has always been the conviction that God is the great protagonist in human life. Most of these narratives were transmitted in ways that were easy to decipher: narratives, images, quotes, poems. In this way they were indelibly engraved in the memory of people and everyone was able to understand them. Centuries later, these narratives began to be recorded and gradually, a collection of texts was created that later became the Old Testament.
The word Pesach means “passage”. Jews celebrating Pesach remember that their ancestors crossed the Red Sea from slavery in Egypt into freedom.
Ramses II (1290-1224 BCE)
Also known as Ramses the Great. He was the third pharaoh of Egypt’s 19th dynasty and the most powerful of all Egyptian rulers.
The narrow sea arm of the Indian Ocean between NE. Africa and SW. Asia, where it creates the ancient Arabian Gulf. At the time of the “Exodus” of the Israelites from Egypt, the Red Sea was also called the Sea of Reeds and was then a lake. The northern part, west of the Sinai Peninsula, is mentioned in the Old Testament book of Exodus as being crossed by the Israelites since, for a millennium, it was crossed only widthwise and never lengthwise.
Someone who is forced, by circumstances or by violence, to leave his or her home or place of permanent residence and seek refuge in a foreign country or country of ethnic origin. Often used in the plural to refer to populations of people moving in groups.
The term literally means the last expression of a person’s will, but in the Bible it is used to describe a Hebrew word meaning “treaty”, “alliance” or “agreement”. However, in addition to the meaning it can have for human relationships, the term is used specifically to denote the particular agreement that governs God’s relationship (Gen. 9:8; Ex. 15:18; 17:1) with the people of Israel (Ex. 19-24) and aims to create the conditions for the salvation of all mankind. The responsibility for initiating the agreement lies with God, who determines its content and terms. But this does not abolish the freedom of man, who is free to accept or reject the agreement, which provides for rights and obligations for both God (faithfulness to promises, love and protection for his people) and man (faith in the One and Only God, and social justice). Thus the covenant does not define a God-master and man-slave relationship, but a father-son relationship (Ex. 4:22).
The list of books used by the writers in the preparation of the book at hand, plus the works of art
and music used as stimuli for the students, along with the sources where they have been found.
The Holy Bible, Old and New Testament, translated from the original texts, Athens: Hellenic Bible Society, 1997 [Η Αγία Γραφή, Παλαιά και Καινή Διαθήκη, Μετάφραση από τα πρωτότυπα κείμενα, Αθήνα: Ελληνική Βιβλική Εταιρία, 1997]
S. Agourides, History of the religion of Israel, Athens: Ellinika Grammata, 1995 [Σ. Αγουρίδης, Ιστορία της Θρησκείας του Ισραήλ, Αθήνα: Ελληνικά Γράμματα, 1995]
Anastassios (Yiannoulatos) Archbishop of Tirana, Co-existance, Athens: Armos, 2016 [Αρχιεπισκόπου Τιράνων Αναστασίου (Γιαννουλάτου), Συνύπαρξη, Αθήνα: Αρμός, 2016]
J. Daniélou, Essai sur le mystère de l’histoire, Paris: Les Éditions du Cerf, 1982 [J. Daniélou, Δοκίμιο για το Μυστήριο της Ιστορίας, μτφρ. Ξ. Κομνηνός, Βόλος: Εκδοτική Δημητριάδος, 2014]
R. Debray, God. An itinerary (trns J. Mehlman), London & New York: Verso, 2004 [Ρ. Ντεμπρέ, Ο Θεός: Μια ιστορική διαδρομή, μτφρ. Μ. Παραδέλη, Αθήνα: Κέδρος, 2005]
Ar. Emmanouil, Dictionary of Hebrew terms and names, Athens: Gavrielides, 2016 [Άρ. Εμμανουήλ, Γλωσσάρι Εβραϊκών όρων και ονομάτων, Αθήνα: Γαβριηλίδης, 2016]
R. Girard, La violence et le sacré, Editions Grasset, 1972 [Ρ. Ζιράρ, Βία και θρησκεία: Αιτία ή αποτέλεσμα; μτφρ. Α. Καλατζής, Εκδ. Νήσος, Αθήνα, 2017]
Ol. Grizopoulou – P. Kazlari, Old Testament, The prehistory of Christianity, Class A Religious Education (Teacher’s book), Athens: The Greek Organization for Publication of School Books (Ο.Ε.D.V.), not dated. [Ολ. Γριζοπούλου - Π. Καζλάρη, Παλαιά Διαθήκη, Η προϊστορία του Χριστιανισμού, Θρησκευτικά Α’ Γυμνασίου, Βιβλίο Εκπαιδευτικού, Αθήνα: Ο.Ε.Δ.Β., χ.χ.]
A. Kokkos et al., Education through the Arts, Athens: Metechmio, 2011 [Α. Κόκκος κ.ά., Εκπαίδευση μέσα από τις Τέχνες, Αθήνα: Μεταίχμιο, 2011]
M. Konstantinou, The Old Testament, Deciphering the universal human heritage, Athens: Armos, 2008. [Μ. Κωνσταντίνου, Παλαιά Διαθήκη, Αποκρυπτογραφώντας την πανανθρώπινη κληρονομιά, Αθήνα: Αρμός, 2008]
Th. N. Papathanassiou, “Anthropology, Culture, Praxis” in S. Fotiou (ed.), Terrorism and Culture, Athens: Armos, 2013 [Θ. Ν. Παπαθανασίου, «Ανθρωπολογία, πολιτισμός, πράξη», στο Σ. Φωτίου (επ.), Τρομοκρατία και Πολιτισμός, Αθήνα: Αρμός, 2013]
Th. N. Papathanassiou (ed.), Violence, religions and culture, Synaxis 98 (2006) [Θ. Ν. Παπαθανασίου (επ.), Η βία, οι θρησκείες και η πολιτισμικότητα, Σύναξη 98 (2006)]
W. Zimmerli, Grundriss der alttestamentlichen Theologie, Dritte, neu durchgesehene Auflage, W. Kohlhammer, 1978 [W. Zimmerli, Επίτομη Θεολογία της Π. Διαθήκης, μτφρ. Β. Στογιάννου, Αθήνα: Άρτος Ζωής, 1981]
L. Zoja, La morte del prossimo, Torino: G. Einaudi, 2009 (Greek translation Μ. Meletiades, Athens: Itamos, 2011) [L. Zoja, Ο θάνατος του πλησίον, μτφρ. Μ. Μελετιάδης, Αθήνα: Ίταμος, 2011]
Dictionary of Modern Greek Language (https://bit.ly/305zcoE)
Works of art
Moses and the Hebrews crossing the Red Sea, pursued by Pharoah: Dura-Europos synagogue,
303 B.C., https://www.flickr.com/photos/24364447@N05/16425564146
Mark Chagall, The Crossing of the Red Sea, https://richardmcbee.com/writings/contemporaryjewish- art/item/chagall-and-the-cross
Ivanka Demchuk, Crossing the Red Sea, https://www.etsy.com/listing/563765092/crossing-thered- sea-original-print-on?ref=landingpage_similar_listing_top-2&pro=1&frs=1
Bartolo di Fredi, The Crossing of the Red Sea, Collegiate Church of San Gemignano, Italy, Fresco, 1356, https://www.christianiconography.info/Wikimedia%20Commons/redSeaBartolo.html
E. Marnay, E. Gold & P. Boone, «Exodus», (song), sung by Edith Piaf, https://safeyoutube.net/ w/45HE
James Pinkerton, Crossing the Red Sea, 2019, https://fineartamerica.com/featured/crossing-thered- sea-james-pinkerton.html
Raphael Posterazzi, Moses Crossing The Red Sea (1483-1520), St. Peter’s Basilica, Vatican City, https://remnantculture.com/wp-content/uploads/pillaroffire.jpg
Maria Yannakaki, Passage [Μαρία Γιαννακάκη, Πέρασμα] 2016, https://www.lifo.gr/guide/ arts/3614